October 2nd

131002_HGT500-1000

Hi All,

As predicted last week, I missed my blog slot on Monday as I was attending my first European MonteCarloTurfgrass Society (ETS) field trip in Monte Carlo. It was quite an eye-opener on lots of fronts, firstly Monaco, what can you say, on the positive side, the weather and normal people were nice, on the negative side, every scrap of space is built on, underground, sideways, upwards, whatever… for me it’s one big chicken coop. That yacht in the background cost a cool £62 million, but the good news for any of you who fancy it, is that it can be hired for a snip….well I say a snip, it’s actually €399,000 a week + of course expenses, whatever that might be ! 🙂 😛

So ok I can see you’re looking at this picture and thinking what a jollie Mark’s been on, lazy so and so, couldn’t be a**ed to do his blog, too busy sitting on the front sipping a lime Cachaca, people watching (ahem), whilst you guys battle the highest disease pressure we’ve probably known….. That’s not an accurate version of events, so what is ?, what do ETS do ?

logo_ETS_120x120

Well they organise very good field trips and conferences on turfgrass research and I have to say after my first experience I’ll be going back because it was invaluable in terms of sitting with researchers from the U.S, southern and northern Europe and talking turfgrass, that’s what floats my boat, big time…

If you want to learn more about them, follow the link here , but here is a flavour of the topics covered…

ETS Program

I’ll be chatting through some of what I learnt in the agronomic notes, but the weather awaits and after having one lad telling me it was 18°C as he drove into work this morning and close to 100% humidity, it needs some discussion….

TempMap021013

Courtesy of Meteoblue

General Weather Information

As you can see from the image above, we are still in the grips of a warm peak in the jet stream and although we’re receiving welcome rain in most places, this combination of weather is making life tricky from an agronomic perspective, so what’s in store for this slightly shorter than usual weather forecast ?

Looking to the rest of Wednesday, we have a heavy band of rain pushing into the south-east corner of Ireland (Munster / Leinster) this evening and that will mostly affect the east coast of Ireland overnight, but it will also push into western Wales and the west coast of the U.K as well later into the night. Elsewhere it’ll be a dull, misty, mild night (again) so not great from a disease perspective I’m afraid.

Moving onto Thursday, that rain band will stay in position overnight over Ireland and the U.K and if anything intensify for the morning rush hour, so potentially some more heavy downpours affecting the east coast of Ireland, particularly Munster in the afternoon. Temperatures will remain mild, high teens, low twenties even in the south-east, accompanied by a south-easterly wind. The rain affecting the west coast of the U.K will drift eastwards to affect the south coast, south-east and Midlands during the afternoon. Later on, a heavier band of rain moves into the south coast of England and rapidly pushes up affecting all of the U.K overnight into Friday. That rain will be heavy, particularly in the north, north-west of England and Scotland.

For Friday, we still have that rain affecting the east coast of Ireland, northern England and Scotland and I expect flooding here for sure. Further south it’ll start off dry, but a weaker band of rain will push into the south-west of England and move across the U.K during the morning / afternoon, so more rain, albeit lighter in nature than Thursday’s for many. Temperatures will be mid to high teens and again that wind will be south / south-east in nature, but much lighter.

For the weekend, it’s not looking too bad….Firstly it’s going to be dry, a little cooler, down to mid-teens, dull, light cloud cover, breaking towards eastern coasts first on Saturday and Sunday afternoon and the winds will be light. Can’t be knocked for early October, except the dew will be back I guess….

Weather Outlook

At this stage it’s looking like high pressure is set to build over the continent and bring back the Indian Summer for next week, so warm during the day (high teens I think) , cool at night (single figures, prompting the return of heavy dews) and dry, with light winds. Looking even further I can see a low forming in the south Atlantic that’ll push up, most likely for late weekend after next and this may bring back the unsettled theme to the weather mid-month.

Agronomic Notes

Ok what to talk about, well it has to be…..

Disease Pressure

Last month saw perhaps unrivalled disease pressure for September, with very warm days, warm / mild nights and very high humidity, > 90% for alot of the U.K. (particularly The Midlands south..). To make matters worse, we also had periods of heavy, localised rainfall and very cold nights, down to 2°C in places and this really affected fungicide uptake and performance.

The GDD and rainfall chart below highlights the periods of the month when disease pressure was high ;

Sept2013HighGDD

The same graph below highlights periods when uptake of systemic fungicides was poor because of cold nights, low GDD and hence low uptake potential of systemic fungicides.

Sept2013LowGDD

So it was a real bitch of a month to be plain, periods of high growth potential when fungal populations were stimulated  and applied fungicides were removed from the leaf over short periods of time followed by sudden drop off in temperatures when uptake of systemic fungicides was poor.

Fungicide Lag

The latter generated a lag in uptake for root-absorbed, XMS (Xylem mobile systemic) fungicides, during which time the plant was un-protected and so disease got a hold. Examples include Tebuconazole, Propiconazole, Azoxystrobin, to name but a few. There was however another problem, just to really make life interesting…

Question – When is a Contact not a Contact ?

The answer is, when it’s a Contact Protectant…. I’ll explain…

At the risk of getting hauled over the coals by certain companies in our industry I’m going to tackle this subject, but a word to them first….any subsequent correspondence will be published in this blog.

…………………………………………..

Currently we have two types of ‘contact’ fungicides available to us in various products / formulations / concentrations / combinations from various companies, they fall into the following categories ;

Contact Protectants

These active ingredients remain by and large on the surface of the leaf and in so doing they affect pathogenic fungal mycelium and spores on the plant leaf surface. They are excellent protectant chemistries for use when the grass leaf is clean or during / prior to periods of dormant growth because their longevity is increased. (They are not removed as fast because the clip rate is low) These include Fludioxonil and Chlorothalonil.

The problem is they have “little or no systemic activity” (to quote one of the companies own literature from the agricultural market). So if you have active disease, (which can be either visible as scarring or if in the early stages, invisible to the naked eye) and you apply a contact protectant, you will not get good control of the disease because the fungus is already IN the leaf and your active is ON the leaf.

To get fast control of active disease (visible or invisible to the naked eye) you’ll need to apply a local penetrant contact chemistry and here we have just one active ingredient, that is Iprodione. This A.I will move from the leaf surface into the leaf itself and thereby control active disease and that’s the difference. You may also achieve control by applying a local penetrant systemic fungicide, again there are a few of these available.

In trying to clear up the confusion on this subject area, I’m not saying one type of chemistry or one companies products are better than the other, that’s not my purpose. They both have advantages and disadvantages, but the key is to understand the difference, understand where your turf is at and select the right type of A.I, regardless of company…

The problem is end-users are being sold products under the broad term ‘contacts’ and as such the understanding is that they will control visible disease quickly, but when they contain contact protectants, they will not, that is not an accurate description of their mode of action and it is not an accurate expectation from the end-user.

So we have a situation like we had last month, It’s mild, muggy and humid….Johnny Bloggs goes out to his greens, sighs as he sees how wet the plant leaf is, even though he’s already taken the dew off once, sighs again when he sees how much grass is in the box and then curses as he sees the first signs of active disease on his greens.  So out comes the fungicide, let’s call it product A, with systemic and contact activity, except the contact features protectant-only chemistry (ies). He applies following the label recommendation and trots off home, content in the knowledge that he has applied the right product.

The next morning he comes in and the disease has got worse, pushed on by the high temperatures, humidity and dew. Ok he thinks, just a little lag before the fungicide kicks in. The next day the scars are growing, they’re much worse and on one or two of his problem greens, he has active mycelium clearly visible, how come ? he thinks, I’ve sprayed a contact and systemic fungicide ….. Not good, not good at all. Overnight the weather changes, we lose the high temperatures and it goes cold, so soil temperatures and growth drops, but the disease carries on moving because the systemic part of the product isn’t yet in the plant at high enough concentrations to achieve control.

What’s more it’s not going to get any better, any quicker, because the slow down in growth rate means less A.I is being taken up from the soil on a daily basis so the balance between disease populations and fungicide concentration in the plant is shifted in favour of the former. By this time a good % of the green is affected, enough for his members to start questioning why he hasn’t sprayed a fungicide or taken any other measures to control the disease.

It can then go a number of ways…..

  1. He can wait, confident that the systemic will eventually build up in sufficient concentration in the plant to achieve control. To make this judgement confidentally, he needs to look at the weather and see if the air / soil temperature and so uptake is likely to improve…This is a big balls approach, particularly if the members are kicking up, but ultimately it’s a balance between how much of the green is affected and how much pressure he’s getting…
  2. He might go back to the ChemSafe and repeat the application, with the same A.I’s and of course he doesn’t achieve any more immediate control than with the first application, plus he’s blown a lot of the clubs money.
  3. He applies a local penetrant chemistry to try and achieve control, this may or may not work by now, depending on how high the disease population has established, how conducive the conditions are for uptake and of course how quickly the chemistry is being removed from the leaf by cutting..

There are other factors in this complex equation, fungicide resistance and fungicide A.I microbial breakdown to name but two…

On the latter subject area, it was reported at the ETS that research work in Norway has shown that in certain situations (presumably where the same product has been applied year after year i.e poor fungicidal rotation) a specific microbial population develops that effectively feeds on the fungicide A.I, because after all these are often carbon chain compounds and that’s what some species of soil microbes feed on. (Actinomycetes for example) So the soil microbes break down the fungicide A.I and in so doing they effectively reduce the amount available for uptake by the plant leading to poor fungicide performance. I’ve read about this before with insecticides in the States like Nemacur, an organophosphate once used to control nematodes, but I’d never read about this ocurring with fungicides.

Now, I’m not saying this is happening everywhere, but it does again highlight the need to practice proper fungicide rotation, that is varying the products applied in terms of active ingredients. It also makes me concerned for the future when we will have less A.I’s available and so carrying this out will be harder to achieve.

I’ll end on a positive….At the ETS, there were two great presentations from researchers in Denmark and Norway, countries where I’d expected the attitude to be completely against pesticides and their use. This wasn’t the case, the presentations highlighted the political agenda present, which by and large was not based on factual evidence, “..not reality, just politics”…But to the contrary, these people had carried out excellent, applied-turf research to show how pesticides behaved in a proper rootzone, how little leached from that very effective grass filter system we all maintain and which A.I’s performed best in this scenario.

They had generated facts, facts that allowed them to make a case, an argument and in so doing, they had actually added a fungicide to the very small list available to the greenkeeper, totally against the political agenda.

Our industry needs more of this work, a lot more of this work if we are to make a case to the politicians / legislators, who make / shape our law. In the U.K, we have the Amenity Forum, a platform to have and take this discussion to the politicians, so we’re on the right track (good work by all those involved), but we need research, much more research, non-partisan in nature, to generate facts, to make our case, for our industry and thereby avoid being lumped in with agriculture.

Ok off the soapbox for this week…

The following GDD data for y.t.d, compiled by the ever-efficient Wendy, can be found at the links below ;

1. Monthly GDD data 2010 – 2013 hereGDDmonthlycomparisonJantoSept2010to2013image

2. Monthly Cumulative GDD data 2010 – 2013 here

GDDmonthlycumulativeJantoSept2010to2013image

3. Daily GDD data September 2013 here

DailyGDDSept2013image

All the best…

Mark Hunt

 

 

 

 

 

 

12 thoughts on “October 2nd

  1. Wayne

    The ETS in Monte Carlo… thres no doubting it Mark your at the front when the tough assignments are getting handed out !
    We might head across for a visit ourselves over the next few days, we are parked at the beach in Antibes now having made our way across from san Sebastian.
    Hopefully the sun will make its return tomorrow, theres a gale of wind here at the minute.

    Reply
      1. Wayne

        Thanks for that Mark ill have a look in a bit. The gale of wind yesterday was followed in the early hours of the morning by the most violent thunder and lighting storm ive heard in a while, when i heard the first clap of thunder i thought something had landed on the roof it was so loud !
        Happy to report all is back to normal this morning, even the sea has calmed down, i cant believe how quick it calmed off there are boats out and fishing already, i know if we had that weather at home it would be a week before you could near the sea.

        Take it easy

        Reply
        1. mark.hunt Post author

          Nice week coming up in Antibes Wayne, up until Thursday when you’ll pick up some slightly cooler weather and rain…up until then it’ll be low twenties and plenty of sun…Enjoy !

          Reply
  2. finbarr o mahony

    hi mark

    probably the worst 3 to 4 weeks of disease pressure i have ever seen here in cork in my 15 years greenkeeping. fusarium on tees, aprons and fairways id say its 10 or 11 years since i see any bit on these areas of our course and its quite widespread on some parts of fairways even in areas that have a high proportion of browntop bent. i sprayed iprodione to greens on 10th of sept went with that as i always find it gives best knockdown once disease is visible and did the trick nicely. greens were scarified, overseeded, and top dressed following week as well as verti drained last week and fusarium started to appear again this sun morning the heavy mechanical inputs and high disease pressure not a good combination for triggering it off. i sprayed propiconzole monday morning before the rain moved in just got enough time to be absorbed. due to the high night time temperatures and that the disease was at very early stages i thought it would work well looking at them today it appears to have done the trick. growth is at a all time high since last thursday i have never seen grass to grow as fast for the start of october even on the fairways that have received no nitrogen.

    regards finbarr

    Reply
    1. mark.hunt Post author

      Hi Finbar,

      Thanks as always for the feedback, it has indeed been a testing time for us all and one I feel slightly uneasy about because I believe we have to raise our game in order to combat periods like this in the future. I feel uneasy because I’m not quite sure how we’re going to do this in the face of E.U legislation, but that’s the challenge we all have to meet.
      With respect to grass growth, you can see that in GDD, it’s quite amazing really and personally I think we need to chuck the calendar out of the window because these kind of events / phases in the weather are now the new norm. Good call on the systemic and the right A.I for sure.

      Mark

      Reply
  3. Patrick Liddy

    With respect Mark, maybe we need to go in another direction.Stop useing the fungicides etc. Let the ” fuss” in and over seed with Fescue. And stop this expansive, unstainable practice.
    Good call on last weeks weather forcast!!

    Reply
    1. mark.hunt Post author

      Hi Patrick,

      Firstly thanks for the feedback, I respect your viewpoint entirely, but like mine, I guess you won’t be surprised to hear I don’t agree 100% ๐Ÿ™‚

      I kind of have a foot in both camps and that feedback was also echo’d at the ETS.

      Personally I don’t believe eradication of pesticides is either desirable or warranted, particularly when you take into account all the trial research done to show that a healthy grass sward is such an efficient filter, that minimal fungicide / pesticide is lost to the environment. Even then, there is precious little evidence to show the harmful effects of that 0.001 ppm of propiconazole for example that ultimately will be broken down by microbial activity anyway because it’s biodegradable. We’re not agriculture, we’re not doing excessive sprays to bare soil areas, where run-off is a clear potential danger. Dovetail that in with the fact that we’re now applying gms of A.I per hectare when until recently we were applying kg and you can see we are moving in the right direction. That doesn’t mean we should carry on regardless, but we must acknowledge the progress we’ve made since the days of DDT for example, that wreaked havoc with our Birds of Prey populations. The problem is our climate and in particular for Ireland and the U.K, the fact that we often have conditions conducive to grass growth close to 12 months of the year (vs. Scandinavia and other areas where they have dormant growth and snow cover). The period between October and March i.e cool, wet with low light suits Poa and this grass effectively out-competes any other at greens height during this period and that includes Fescue, whether Red or Chewings. For me that doesn’t mean we should accept Poa because ultimately we do have to move away from this process, on that we agree Patrick, but I think the answer lies in plant breeding and bentgrass, not necessarily Creeping, but colonial / Browntop species whose disease resistance is that much higher in terms of Fusarium.
      I believe limitation of pesticides, bentgrass with Poa, coupled with the right education at club level that provides the golf course manager / superintendent with the tools and the time to do the necessary cultural work to dry the surface out, lower the organic matter content and thereby lower the disease pressure naturally, without the requirement for endless pesticide sprays is the way forward. That said, it’s just my opinion.

      Hope the forecast was correct for Mullingar !

      Reply
  4. Greg Evans

    Very good blog as usual Mark. Good understanding of how fungicides work and well worth reading.

    Well done!

    Greg

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.